isolated woman pain right shoulder

Key Takeaways

  • The most common signs of a torn rotator cuff are shoulder pain at night, pain when lifting your arm, and weakness when lifting or rotating your arm.
  • Many rotator cuff tears happen slowly from wear and tear, not from one dramatic injury, so the early signs are easy to mistake for ordinary soreness.
  • Weakness is an important clue, because some tears cause little pain but still make the arm harder to use.
  • Only an exam and imaging, such as an MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) or ultrasound, can confirm a tear and show how large it is.
  • Sports Medicine & Joint Replacement Specialists provides expert shoulder injury care across Greater Pittsburgh, with offices in Pittsburgh, Greensburg, and Warrendale. Request an appointment online with Sports Medicine & Joint Replacement Specialists if your shoulder symptoms aren’t going away.

APPOINTMENTS

Common Rotator Cuff Tear Symptoms

A rotator cuff tear happens when one or more of the four rotator cuff tendons partly or fully pulls away from the upper arm bone. According to the Cleveland Clinic’s guide to rotator cuff tears, common symptoms include:

  • Pain, difficulty, or weakness when you raise, lower, or rotate your arm
  • Popping, clicking, or crackling when you move your arm in certain positions
  • Shoulder pain that gets worse at night or when your arm is resting
  • Shoulder weakness and trouble lifting objects

What Does a Torn Rotator Cuff Feel Like?

The feeling varies from person to person. Cleveland Clinic describes it as anything from a dull ache deep in the shoulder to a sharp, stabbing pain.

The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) adds that pain is often felt in the front or side of the shoulder. It may travel down the side of your arm, especially with overhead movements like throwing a ball or reaching into a high cabinet.

How Weakness and Limited Motion Point to a Tear?

Pain gets most of the attention, but weakness is often the more telling sign. Your rotator cuff helps lift and rotate your arm. When a tendon is torn, those motions can become harder.

According to the AAOS rotator cuff tear FAQ, you may notice trouble with routine tasks like:

  • Combing your hair
  • Reaching behind you to slip your arm into a coat sleeve
  • Lifting items to shoulder height or above

AAOS also points out that some rotator cuff tears are not painful at all. These tears can still cause arm weakness. If your shoulder feels weaker than the other one, don’t ignore it just because it doesn’t hurt much.

Sudden Tears vs. Gradual, Overuse-Related Tears

Rotator cuff tears have two main causes: a sudden injury or slow wear over time. Knowing the difference can help you understand your symptoms.

Sudden (Acute) Tears

Acute means sudden. An acute tear can happen if you fall on an outstretched arm or lift something too heavy with a jerking motion. According to AAOS, these tears usually cause:

  • Intense pain right away
  • A snapping feeling in the shoulder
  • Immediate weakness in the upper arm

AAOS notes that most rotator cuff tears in young adults come from this type of injury, such as a fall.

Gradual (Degenerative) Tears

Degenerative means caused by wear over time. AAOS explains that most rotator cuff tears happen this way, as the tendon slowly wears down with age. Risk is higher for:

  • People over age 40
  • People who do repeated lifting or overhead work, like painters and carpenters
  • Athletes in sports such as tennis and baseball

These tears often start with mild pain that only shows up when you lift your arm overhead. Over time, the pain may show up at rest and no longer improve with over-the-counter medicine.

Rotator Cuff Strain vs. Tear: How Symptoms Differ

People often use the word “strain” to describe a shoulder that feels sore or overworked. According to the Mayo Clinic’s overview of rotator cuff injuries, rotator cuff injuries range from simple inflammation to complete tendon tears.

The signs below can help you notice which end of that range your symptoms may fall on. Still, they can’t replace an exam.

ClueMore Like Irritation or a Minor InjuryMore Like a Tear
How did it start?After a busy day of overhead work or activityAfter a fall or jerking lift, or slowly worsening over months
Pain patternSore with certain movements, eases with restPain at night or at rest, often while lying on that side
StrengthArm feels sore but strength is normalReal weakness when lifting or rotating the arm
Sounds or sensationsUsually nonePopping, clicking, or crackling; a snap at the time of injury
Response to over-the-counter medicinePain easesPain stops responding over time

Why You Can’t Tell for Sure on Your Own

Even doctors rely on testing to confirm a tear. AAOS notes that X-rays don’t show tendons, so a shoulder with a rotator cuff tear often looks normal on an X-ray. An MRI or ultrasound can show the tendons, the size of a tear, and where it is located.

When Do These Symptoms Warrant a Specialist Evaluation?

AAOS recommends seeing an orthopedic specialist if you’ve injured your shoulder or have ongoing shoulder and arm pain. Early diagnosis and treatment may help prevent loss of strength and motion.

Schedule an evaluation if you notice:

  • Shoulder pain that lasts or keeps returning
  • Pain that wakes you at night
  • Weakness when lifting or rotating your arm
  • Redness, swelling, or tenderness around the shoulder joint

Seek care promptly if your arm becomes weak right after a fall or injury.

At Sports Medicine & Joint Replacement Specialists, a shoulder evaluation is the first step toward a personalized plan. Many patients start with non-surgical treatments like physical therapy and ultrasound-guided injections. When needed, the practice also offers arthroscopic shoulder surgery, a minimally invasive procedure that uses a small camera to diagnose and treat joint problems through small incisions.

Find Out What’s Really Going On in Your Shoulder

A torn rotator cuff doesn’t always announce itself with one big injury. Night pain, weakness, and pain that keeps getting worse are all signs that your shoulder needs a closer look.

Request an appointment online with Sports Medicine & Joint Replacement Specialists for a shoulder injury evaluation at our Pittsburgh, Greensburg, or Warrendale office

Appointments

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if I tore my rotator cuff?

Common signs include pain at night, pain when lifting or lowering your arm, weakness when lifting or rotating your arm, and crackling in the shoulder. A shoulder specialist can confirm a tear with an exam and imaging, such as an MRI or ultrasound.

What are the signs of rotator cuff injury after a fall?

A rotator cuff injury after a fall may cause intense pain right away, a snapping feeling, and sudden weakness in the arm. If your arm feels weak right after an injury, get checked promptly.

How can I tell a rotator cuff strain vs. tear?

Irritation or a minor injury usually causes soreness that improves with rest. A tear is more likely to cause night pain, real arm weakness, and pain that stops responding to over-the-counter medicine. Only an exam and imaging can tell for sure.

Can a rotator cuff tear show up on an X-ray?

No. X-rays don’t show tendons, so a rotator cuff tear won’t appear on one. Doctors still use X-rays to rule out other problems, such as arthritis, and may order an MRI or ultrasound to see the tendons.

Where can I find a shoulder specialist in Pittsburgh, PA?

Sports Medicine & Joint Replacement Specialists treats shoulder injuries at three offices in the Greater Pittsburgh area: Pittsburgh, Greensburg, and Warrendale. You can request an appointment online.